Requirements of the first team and a casualty list prevented Aberdeen "A" fielding their full strength against Hearts "A' in the second stage of the Scottish 2nd XI. Cup competition at Tynecastle. A re-arranged side, with Forbes at centre-half, put up a good fight, but in the end had to retire beaten by 2 goals to 0. There was no scoring in the first period, during which Hearts were slightly more aggressive, but McSevich, Muir, and Forsyth offered a stubborn resistance, while Carroll was always ready to lead Aberdeen to the attack. Early in the second half, McNeill put Hearts on the lead. For a time it looked as if Aberdeen would draw level, but in another Hearts' attack Edgar headed a second goal. In the closing stages Aberdeen strove hard, but their forwards were not effective in front of goal. Outstanding for Aberdeen were McSevich, Forsyth, Muir, Ross, and Carroll, and for Hearts, King, Harley, T. White, McNeill and Edgar.
Source: Press & Journal, 1st March 1926