Source: The Scotsman, 12th March 1928
GOAL-LESS PERIOD.
Even play marked the opening, and both ends were raided without either goalkeeper being called upon. Ultimately Love had a chance to shoot, but Paton jumped in and cleared, and later Smith was badly off the mark with an attempt at a shot. After having forced a corner, Thistle almost scored, Blackwell deflecting a fine shot by Grove. Following a raid and centre by Smith, Love shot over the Thistle goal, with Jackson out of his charge. At the other end Blackwell saved an oblique shot by Elliot. Other two corners followed to Thistle, but these were cleared, and when Aberdeen retaliated Merrie met a centre by Love, but sent the ball too far ahead, and Paton cleared. At the other end Blackwell stopped a header by Grove and got into position in time to save a shot from Boardman. Subsequently Aberdeen attacked. Love just failed to gather from Merrie after a run and centre by Smith, but later the home right winger had a fine shot brilliantly saved by Jackson. A snap-shot by Gibson was smartly picked up by Blackwell, and then the Thistle goalkeeper cleared from Smith. During fierce attacks by Aberdeen two claims for penalty infringements against Thistle defenders were turned down, and a section of the spectators expressed disapproval. Towards the interval play ruled from end to end. Gibson had a shot deflected by Livingstone, and the Thistle goalkeeper dealt with efforts by Smith and Cheyne. There was no score at half-time.A DISPUTED SCORE.
Thistle had to face a fierce blizzard when the game resumed, and were immediately forced on the defensive. Merrie and Cheyne both shot wide from favourable positions, and subsequently the home forwards were at fault in not indulging in more shooting. In a break-away by Thistle, Salisbury sent behind, and later Grove, when well placed repeated the performance. There was another claim for a penalty for Aberdeen when a Thistle defender appeared to handle a shot by Cheyne, but again the referee decided there was no infringement. Following a period of mid-field play, Aberdeen forced a corner, and subsequent to the flag kick McHale headed through in a scrimmage. Thistle protested against the legality of the goal, but the referee was adamant. Following this the Aberdeen goal had a narrow escape. Black passed back wide of Blackwell, but Livingstone intervened when a goal seemed certain. Subsequently play ruled in favour of Aberdeen, and from centre by Love, Yorston from close range put Aberdeen further ahead. Thistle retaliated for a time, and McDougall came near with a header, but later Aberdeen exerted strong pressure, and Merrie, accepting a pass from Cheyne, went on to beat O'Hare and gave the Thistle goalkeeper no chance with a fine shot. Three goals ahead, Aberdeen had no great difficulty in maintaining their advantage.Source: Press & Journal, 12th March 1928
Source: Bon-Accord, 17th March, 1928