Source: The Scotsman, 7th January 1924
GOAL FOR MILLER.
The Edinburgh team's goal had been several times in danger before Smith, at the end of half an hour's play, sent on a powerful shot that found the upright. The ball rebounded to Miller, who, shooting first-time, gave W. White no chance. That was the only goal of the opening period, during which Aberdeen held the whip hand. The visiting forwards were scarcely ever in touch with Blackwell and on the other hand the home attackers had numerous efforts either blocked or charged down in front of White's goal.ONE FOR GRANT
Play was much more equal in the second half, but even below strength the Aberdeen forwards were always more dangerous in front of goal. Following a corner kick, Grant increased the home team's lead after five minutes' play, the ball finding the net off the upright. Hearts subsequently enjoyed a spell of pressure, and Blackwell had to save from Ramage, J. White, and Murphy, but Aberdeen again took up the attack, and Smith sent a centre on to the top of the bar. J. White shot into the net for the visitors, but the whistle had previously sounded for offside. In the closing stages Hearts played up strongly, and after Blackwell had saved at full length from Kerr, Welsh, from a suspiciously offside position got through to beat the Aberdeen. goalkeeper.PLAYERS WHO SHONE.
Play throughout was keen and interesting, without, however, touching a very high standard. Considering the big handicap under which they played, Aberdeen were deserving winners, and had they been at full strength throughout the margin in their favour would probably have been more in accordance with their undoubted superiority. Blackwell was a skilful and safe goalkeeper, and Hutton and Jackson proved a happy combination at back. The half-backs never let the Tynecastle forwards out of control, and while Davidson and MacLachlan gave a capital display in the wing positions, Dick deserves praise for his fine work at centre-half, a position he essayed with much success. He kept a firm grip of John White, and his efforts at constructive play suggested possibilities. The forwards worked harmoniously, and even after Moir had retired, were more dangerous than the Tynecastle van. Grant was the most effective, as, while the best shot view, he opened the game, and accounted for many good passes. Paton at inside right, showed much cleverness, and Miller and Smith completed a line that had not really a weak link.DISAPPOINTING HEARTS.
Hearts gave the most disappointing display of any Tynecastle team at Pittodrie in recent years. W. White, in goal, effected many clever saves, although fumbling the ball more than once. Wilson was the better back, and in the half-back line Wright and Ramage were seen to advantage. The forwards never worked with much harmony. J. White would have been dangerous, but was too well watched by Dick, and of the others Kerr, at inside right, was best, but the line was not well balanced.Source: Press & Journal, 7th January 1924